| OT Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Uc | 1-G | on Uc30 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | UCumberlands wins toss and will play defense |
| Uc | 1-G | on Uc30 | WISE ball on UC25. |
| Wise | 1-G | on Uc25 | 1st and 10. |
| Wise | 1-10 | on Uc25 | Randy Hippeard pass incomplete to Aric Evans. |
| Wise | 2-10 | on Uc25 | Randy Hippeard pass incomplete to H. Abdul-Saboor, QB hurry by Alex Wright. |
| Wise | 3-10 | on Uc25 | Randy Hippeard pass complete to Ra'Shad Morgan for 12 yards to the UC13, 1ST DOWN WISE (PJ Hughes;Shovon Patton). |
| Wise | 1-10 | on Uc13 | Ra'Shad Morgan rush for 2 yards to the UC11, out-of-bounds (Desmond Cruver). |
| Wise | 2-8 | on Uc11 | Randy Hippeard pass complete to Matt Barbour for 7 yards to the UC4, out-of-bounds. |
| Wise | 3-1 | on Uc04 | Ra'Shad Morgan rush for loss of 1 yard to the UC5 (PJ Hughes;Alex Wright). |
| Wise | 4-2 | on Uc05 | Timeout UVa-Wise, clock 15:00. |
| Wise | 4-2 | on Uc05 | Lance Ayers field goal attempt from 23 GOOD, clock 15:00. |
| UVa-Wise 38, U. Cumberlands 35 |
| Wise | 1-G | on Wise30 | UC ball on WISE25. |
| Uc | 1-G | on Wise25 | 1st and 10. |
| Uc | 1-10 | on Wise25 | Ricky Walker rush for 1 yard to the WISE24 (Reg. Dorsainvil;Danny Hinkle). |
| Uc | 2-9 | on Wise24 | Rod Mason rush for 5 yards to the WISE19 (Reg. Dorsainvil). |
| Uc | 3-4 | on Wise19 | Rod Mason rush for 6 yards to the WISE13, 1ST DOWN UC (Matt Gular;Brandon Moore). |
| Uc | 1-10 | on Wise13 | Ricky Walker rush for 2 yards to the WISE11 (Ben Robertson). |
| Uc | 2-8 | on Wise11 | Moses Cochran rush for 5 yards to the WISE6 (Matt Gular;Jahmal Potter). |
| Uc | 3-3 | on Wise06 | Ricky Walker rush for 3 yards to the WISE3, 1ST DOWN UC (Ben Robertson;Chas Johnson). |
| Uc | 1-G | on Wise03 | Ricky Walker rush for 3 yards to the WISE0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| U. Cumberlands 41, UVa-Wise 38 |
| Uc | 1-G | on Wise03 | End of game, clock 15:00. |
| | Drive: 21 plays, 0 yards, TOP 16:13 |
